Posted in Sarah's Attic Of Treasures

Sweet Potato Or Pumpkin Pie? 

The Chicago Tribune

Dahleen GlantonContact ReporterChicago Tribune

If you’ve never lived in the South and you’re not African-American, chances are you’re clueless about the fuss over sweet potato pie.

Patti LaBelle and Wal-Mart scored a hit recently when they introduced a sweet potato pie promoted as the singer’s own recipe. The pies, with Patti’s smiling face on the box, flew off store shelves. The manufacturer can’t bake them fast enough.Sweet potato pie is pumpkin’s Southern cousinIt’s commonly made using almost identical ingredients – eggs, condensed milk, cinnamon, nutmeg – except that sweet potatoes are used in place of pumpkin. The flavor is similar, too, but where pumpkin pie is dense and creamy, most sweet potato pieshave more texture, and the filling is lighter and more airy.Nov 11, 2014

Thanksgiving is coming in a few days and ever since the first one, there has always been a debate on which pie is better – PUMPKIN or SWEET POTATO? Growing up we always had sweet potato pie. I like sweet potato pie better than pumpkin pie because of the smoother texture and it is usually less tart. But say that in the wrong household and you could get banned from Thanksgiving dinner forever!

Which one do you prefer for Thanksgiving – Pumpkin or Sweet Potato?

Read More: Pumpkin Pie VS Sweet Potato Pie – Which is Better? |

Serious Eats>


Pumpkin pie vs. sweet potato pie


By Serious Eats.

As the eatin’ season begins, it seems to me that someone out there can discuss the difference between pumpkin pie and sweet potato pie. I’ve only had SP pie once, a good while back. But it seems to me that they’re both basically the same thing, a custard with cooked, pureed flesh and similar spicing, which is variations on cinnamon/ginger/nutmeg/mace. But that’s only a theoretical description. Lots of folks seem to prefer one to the other. Help me out here. What’s the difference? Why do you prefer one to the other?

Sweet potato pie is pumpkin’s Southern cousin – | The Wichita .

The pie is a Thanksgiving staple in African-American and Southern homes and is just as easy to prepare as pumpkin.





  • The first time Gregory Cole ever tasted pumpkin pie, he was a grown man.

    It was Thanksgiving, and he was in the army, stationed far from home. His thankfulness quotient rocketed when he spotted an orange-colored pie.

    Until he learned that the pie was pumpkin.

    “I said, ‘Wait a minute. Who did this?’” he remembers with a laugh.

    Cole, who today hef and instructor at the Butler County Culinary Arts program, grew up eating sweet potato pie exclusively. The dessert was always the centerpiece of his family Thanksgivings, and no one made sweet potato pie better than his grandmother.

    Read more here:


    My real name is Debra (Debbie Sue). Sarah is a nickname given to me in high school. My husband has always called me that so here in Florida It's all I am known by. I was born and raised in Illinois. My son and I moved to Colorado in 1982. I taught school for 17 years. Then I ran a homeschooling/preschool/daycare until 2006 when I moved to Florida after my son, Bobby died suddenly. He was almost 26. Danny and I live and work at a state park here. I miss the mountains and climate of Colorado. I miss snow and the four seasons. I miss Bobby.

    Please Comment. I don't care how long or how short. I want to hear from you.

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google photo

    You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

    Connecting to %s

    Her Writing Haven

    A place where words come alive

    The Real Carrie Brown

    Recipes and adventures from a splendid single life


    People and Trends

    Comfort Spring

    Home, Garden, Food & Wellness

    CBS Denver

    Find Denver news, Colorado news, Colorado weather forecasts and sports reports including Denver Broncos at

    Marriage Gems

    Research-based marriage tips and insights

    Bacon and Cream

    a Keto Lifestyle Blog

    The Dads: Harris & Dave

    Cooking, Decorating, Entertaining, & More!

    The Pajama Chef

    where the secret ingredient is love

    Living Our Days

    Gaining a heart of wisdom

    Finding Hope and Healing

    A Safe Place for Survivors of Sexual Abuse with Tools and Inspiration from a Gospel Perspective

    Worshipful Living

    Sowing seeds of worship in everyday life

    Small Town Woman

    Cooking & Entertaining

    Family Globetrotters

    Travel Tips For The Whole Family

    Create With Joy

    Infuse Creativity In All You Do

    helping you find hope and freedom from the despair of your chronic health issues so that you feel good enough to love life again!

    lori rose, PhD, board certified holistic nutrition consultant, Certified nutrition professional, registered herbalist (AHG), National Board Certified Holistic Wellness Coach (NBC-HWC), Functional Diagnostic Nutrition Practitioner (FDN-P)

    %d bloggers like this: